
The person at the center of this case
Carnell 'Nell' Sledge and Kate Brown
Justice for Carnell 'Nell' Sledge and Kate Brown — the trail went cold in 2025, but the truth hasn't.
Start here
Who was the man sitting in a nearby truck that witnesses reported? Did he see anything unusual?
What was the murder weapon and where is it now? Ballistics could identify the killer if the gun is recovered.
Why did Carnell agree to meet Kate so close to his planned 5:00-5:30 pm family dinner? What was urgent enough to change his plans?
On June 4, 2019, Carnell 'Nell' Sledge and Kate Brown, close friends for ten years, were shot to death on a park bench at Rocky River Reservation near Cleveland during broad daylight while surrounded by joggers, dog walkers, and cyclists. The killer remains unknown; nothing was stolen, and no witnesses have come forward despite the public setting, suggesting the assailant knew the park well and was confident in their escape. Five years later, the case remains unsolved, with investigators pursuing theories including hate crime, gang initiation, and jealous romantic partners, but family and law enforcement continue seeking tips that could finally identify the murderer.
Try asking
Beyond the top three above — each detail below could be the thread that pulls this case open.
How did the killer commit two murders in broad daylight with numerous park visitors present without anyone hearing gunshots or seeing the assailant flee?
Gang graffiti was present near the park—could this be a gang-related killing, or was the location chosen deliberately to misdirect investigators?
Even the smallest detail could be the key to solving this case.
Official wording
The murder of Carnell Sledge
Carnell texted Kate around 4:00 pm asking if she wanted to meet up
Kate and Carnell sat down on a park bench shortly after 5:00 pm to chat
A couple looking to kayak discovered Carnell shot multiple times in the head near the bench and Kate face-down in the shallow creek at 5:18 pm