
The person at the center of this case
Ellen R. Greenberg, age 27
Justice for Ellen R. Greenberg, age 27 — the trail went cold in 2025, but the truth hasn't.
Start here
Why did pathologist Marlon Osbourne reverse the manner of death from homicide to suicide without explanation to the family, and what evidence specifically supported this change?
How can approximately 20 stab wounds, including wounds to the chest, neck, and scalp, be consistent with suicide rather than homicide?
The apartment door was locked from inside and the rear patio was six stories high with undisturbed snow—how could an intruder have exited, and why would a suicide victim lock the door?
Ellen Greenberg, a 27-year-old Philadelphia teacher, was found dead in her apartment on January 26, 2011, with a knife embedded in her chest and approximately 20 stab wounds. The Medical Examiner initially ruled her death a homicide, but pathologist Marlon Osbourne reversed the ruling to suicide weeks later without explanation, citing web searches for suicide methods and text messages showing mental distress. Her family has spent over a decade challenging the suicide classification through civil litigation and expert forensic review, arguing the evidence—including the nature and number of wounds, the locked apartment, and inconsistencies in the body's position—is inconsistent with suicide.
Try asking
Beyond the top three above — each detail below could be the thread that pulls this case open.
What did the fiancé Samuel Goldberg observe or know that might explain the inconsistency between his 911 call description of Ellen lying on her back and police reports of her slumped against cabinets?
What do the web searches for 'methods of committing suicide' and the text messages showing mental distress reveal about Ellen's state of mind, and are they sufficient to override the physical evidence?
Even the smallest detail could be the key to solving this case.
Official wording
Case of Ellen Greenberg
Ellen's mother reported a pleasant phone conversation with no indication of distress as they were heading to work
Samuel Goldberg left Ellen at the apartment to go to the gym
Goldberg returned and found the door locked from inside; he attempted to contact Ellen via text, phone, and email for approximately one hour
Goldberg forced entry with apartment security present and discovered Ellen on the kitchen floor with a knife in her chest; 911 called
PFD Medic-5 pronounced Ellen dead at the scene