The person at the center of this case
Kathryn Menendez (age 17) and Sarah Rae Boehm (age 14)
Cold Case · Open
31 years waiting · since 1994
KATHRYN MENENDEZ
Justice for Kathryn Menendez (age 17) and Sarah Rae Boehm (age 14) — the trail went cold in 1994, but the truth hasn't.
Start here
Key leads to think about
🎯
suspect
Lead #1Who murdered both girls and why were they transported to a remote Ohio location two hours from the Pennsylvania victim's home?
⏰
timeline
Lead #2What was the connection between the two disappearances occurring within six weeks of each other in different states?
🔍
evidence
Lead #3What forensic evidence links the two murders and suggests they were committed by the same perpetrator?
Seventeen-year-old Kathryn Menendez disappeared on August 25, 1994, from Portage County, Ohio, and was found strangled days later on an oil road near Berlin Reservoir. Her case is linked to fourteen-year-old Sarah Rae Boehm, who went missing from Pennsylvania in July 1994 and was discovered in the same Ohio state park in November—both bodies found less than half a mile apart. Investigators believe the murders are connected and seek information about how these young women came to be killed in this remote location and by whom.
Case
#475
FBI Pittsburgh Field Office, Portage County Ohio Sheriff, Beaver County Pennsylvania Police
Try asking
Claim this imported case
A one-time $10 claim transfers this imported case workspace to your account. You get 10 uploads for this case, 25 daily AI questions for this case, and public tips with files route to you.
10 uploads25 AI questions/day
This does not start a subscription. When the included limits are reached, the Personal plan unlocks more workspace capacity.
More leads to consider
Beyond the top three above — each detail below could be the thread that pulls this case open.
📍
location
Lead #4Why were both bodies deposited in the same remote state park area near Berlin Reservoir?
👁️
witness
Lead #5Were there any witnesses to suspicious activity on the oil road or near Berlin Reservoir during late August and early November 1994?
Have information about any of these leads?
Even the smallest detail could be the key to solving this case.
Official wording
Source Narrative
Murder Victim Alliance, Portage County, Ohio August 25, 1994 Caution: Sarah Rae Boehm , a fourteen-year-old female teen, was reported missing by her parents on July 14, 1994, to local law enforcement in Beaver County, Pennsylvania. Several months later, on November 4, 1994, Sarah's remains were discovered in the "Berlin Reservoir," located within an Ohio state park, Portage County, Ohio.
This rural community in Ohio was located approximately two hours away from the victim's home in Pennsylvania. Additionally, Kathryn Menendez, another female teen victim, went missing on August 25, 1994, and her nude body was found several days later on an oil road near the "Berlin Reservoir." Kathryn had been strangled to death.
Both Sarah and Kathryn's bodies were located approximately 1/2 mile apart in the same Ohio state park. Seventeen-year-old Kathryn was from Portage County, Ohio.
Information is being sought in both cases. Specifically, how Boehm from Pennsylvania ended up murdered in Ohio and information regarding the murder of Menendez.
Investigators believe the two cases may be related. The FBI from both Pennsylvania and Ohio have been working closely with local law enforcement from Portage County, Ohio, as well as Beaver County, Pennsylvania.
Timeline of Events
👤
1994-07-14
Sarah Rae Boehm reported missing
Fourteen-year-old Sarah Rae Boehm was reported missing by her parents to Beaver County, Pennsylvania law enforcement.
👤
1994-08-25
Kathryn Menendez disappears
Seventeen-year-old Kathryn Menendez went missing from Portage County, Ohio.
🔍
1994-08-29
Kathryn Menendez body found
Kathryn's nude body was discovered on an oil road near Berlin Reservoir; cause of death determined to be strangulation.
🔍
1994-11-04
Sarah Rae Boehm remains discovered
Sarah's remains were found in Berlin Reservoir, approximately half a mile from where Kathryn was discovered.
Key Locations
Interactive map showing important locations related to this case
Case Information
Incident:July 14, 1994
Last Updated:May 12, 2026
Leave a comment
Comments
Case Information
Incident:July 14, 1994
Last Updated:May 12, 2026