CrimeOwl AI logoCrimeOwl AI
CasesBlogPricingAbout
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Cases
  4. /
  5. Missing Person: Melissa Jo or Joe Sermons
Back to CasesMore Cases
Melissa Jo or Joe Sermons

The person at the center of this case

Melissa Jo or Joe Sermons

Case
#1862
SourceNamus MissingUpdated Jun 2, 2026
Polk County Sheriff's Office - Bartow
Missing Person · Open
34 years waiting · since 1992

Missing Person: Melissa Jo or Joe Sermons

Justice for Melissa Jo or Joe Sermons — the trail went cold in 1992, but the truth hasn't.

Start here

Key leads to think about

🎯
suspect
Lead #1

Who killed Larry Costine and what was the motive for his murder?

👤
person
Lead #2

What was the nature of Sermons' relationship with Costine and were there any conflicts?

🔍
evidence
Lead #3

What evidence was recovered from Costine's residence and does it connect to Sermons' disappearance?

Melissa Jo Sermons, a 26-year-old woman involved in rodeo culture, was last seen on May 3, 1992, at a rodeo in Dade City with her date Larry Costine. Two days later, Costine was found shot to death in his North Lakeland home, but Sermons has never been located. The circumstances surrounding her disappearance and Costine's murder remain unexplained, making this case critical for anyone with information about that weekend.

Case
#1862
SourceNamus MissingUpdated Jun 2, 2026
Polk County Sheriff's Office - Bartow

Try asking

Claim this imported case

A one-time $10 claim transfers this imported case workspace to your account. You get 10 uploads for this case, 25 daily AI questions for this case, and public tips with files route to you.

10 uploads25 AI questions/day

This does not start a subscription. When the included limits are reached, the Personal plan unlocks more workspace capacity.

More leads to consider

Beyond the top three above — each detail below could be the thread that pulls this case open.

👁️
witness
Lead #4

Were there witnesses at the Dade City rodeo who saw Sermons and Costine together that evening?

💡
clue
Lead #5

Sermons was wearing distinctive jewelry including a horseshoe ring with diamonds and a gold rope chain with cross—has anyone spotted these items?

Have information about any of these leads?

Even the smallest detail could be the key to solving this case.

Official wording

Source Narrative

NamUs case MP5756. Missing person: Melissa Jo or Joe Sermons.

Last known contact: 1992-05-03 in Lakeland, Polk, FL. Circumstances: The victim was last seen at a rodeo in Dade City with her date, Larry Costine.

On 05/05/92, Costine was found shot to death inside his North Lakeland residence. Sermons has not been seen or heard from since.

She worked with horses and was involved in the rodeo culture. Demographics: 26 years, Female, White / Caucasian.

Physical description: 5 ft 10 in, 175 lbs, hair: Blond/Strawberry, eyes: Green. Clothing and accessories: Accessories: gray purse with two straps; Jewelry: horse shoe ring with diamonds, black watch, rope (gold colored) chain with cross.

Investigating agency: Polk County Sheriff's Office - Bartow | 92-051864.

Timeline of Events

👁️
1992-05-03

Last Sighting

Melissa Jo Sermons last seen at a rodeo in Dade City with her date Larry Costine

🔍
1992-05-05

Body Discovery

Larry Costine found shot to death inside his North Lakeland residence

Key Locations
Interactive map showing important locations related to this case

Case Information

Incident:May 3, 1992
Last Updated:June 3, 2026

Have Information?

Any information, no matter how small, could be crucial to solving this case.

Phone: 8632986200
You can remain anonymous

Leave a comment

Comments

Case Information

Incident:May 3, 1992
Last Updated:June 3, 2026

Have Information?

Any information, no matter how small, could be crucial to solving this case.

Phone: 8632986200
You can remain anonymous