CrimeOwl AI logoCrimeOwl AI
CasesBlogPricingAboutLaw Enforcement
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Cases
  4. /
  5. Missing Person: Timothy Lee Benally
Back to CasesMore Cases
Timothy Lee Benally

The person at the center of this case

Timothy Lee Benally

Case
#1684
SourceNamus MissingUpdated May 21, 2026
Chandler Police Department
Missing Person Β· Open
34 years waiting Β· since 1992

Missing Person: Timothy Lee Benally

Justice for Timothy Lee Benally β€” the trail went cold in 1992, but the truth hasn't.

Start here

Key leads to think about

πŸ‘οΈ
witness
Lead #1

Who is the unidentified pastor that encountered Timothy in the mid-1990s and hosted him at a church in Mesa?

πŸ“
location
Lead #2

Can the specific homeless encampment in Mesa where the wife met the pastor be identified and searched for additional witnesses?

πŸ’‘
clue
Lead #3

Why has there been no activity on Timothy's Social Security or VA benefits since 1992β€”does this indicate he may have passed away?

Timothy Lee Benally, a US Navy veteran, disappeared in summer 1992 from the Navajo Nation and was last known to be in Mesa, Arizona. His wife reported him missing and later encountered a pastor in 1998 who recalled hosting Timothy at a church in the mid-1990s, suggesting he may have experienced homelessness. Despite decades of investigation, Timothy's current whereabouts remain unknown, with no activity on his Social Security or VA benefits accounts.

Case
#1684
SourceNamus MissingUpdated May 21, 2026
Chandler Police Department

Try asking

Claim this imported case

A one-time $10 claim transfers this imported case workspace to your account. You get 10 uploads for this case, 25 daily AI questions for this case, and public tips with files route to you.

10 uploads25 AI questions/day

This does not start a subscription. When the included limits are reached, the Personal plan unlocks more workspace capacity.

More leads to consider

Beyond the top three above β€” each detail below could be the thread that pulls this case open.

πŸ‘€
person
Lead #4

Are there other homeless individuals or church members from the mid-1990s Mesa area who may have known Timothy?

Have information about any of these leads?

Even the smallest detail could be the key to solving this case.

Official wording

Source Narrative

NamUs case MP158841. Missing person: Timothy Lee Benally.

Last known contact: 1992-01-01 in Mesa, Maricopa, AZ. Circumstances: Timothy Lee Benally was reported missing by his wife stating he has been missing since 1992.

She stated no one in the family has seen Timothy since he left her family's home up in the Navajo Nation in Summer of 1992. His wife claims she ventured to a homeless encampment in an unknown location within Mesa in 1998.

There, she spoke with an unidentified pastor of a church who remembered hosting Timothy in the mid 90s. At this point, Timothy's whereabouts are unknown.

The Department of Veteran Affairs confirmed no benefits have been claimed by Timothy, who is a US Navy Veteran. Additionally, the Social Security Administration advised no SSI benefits have been withdrawn on Timothy's behalf.

Demographics: 34 years, Male, American Indian / Alaska Native. Physical description: 5 ft 10 in, 200 lbs, hair: Black, eyes: Brown.

Investigating agency: Chandler Police Department | 2026-12197 | 2026-01-26.

Timeline of Events

πŸ‘€
1992-06-01

Timothy Lee Benally disappears

Timothy left his family's home in the Navajo Nation in summer 1992 and has not been seen since by family members.

πŸ‘₯
1998-01-01

Wife encounters pastor at homeless encampment

Timothy's wife ventured to a homeless encampment in Mesa and spoke with an unidentified pastor who recalled hosting Timothy at a church in the mid-1990s.

Key Locations
Interactive map showing important locations related to this case

Case Information

Incident:June 1, 1992
Last Updated:September 26, 2026

Have Information?

Any information, no matter how small, could be crucial to solving this case.

Phone: 4807824000
You can remain anonymous

Leave a comment

Comments

Case Information

Incident:June 1, 1992
Last Updated:September 26, 2026

Have Information?

Any information, no matter how small, could be crucial to solving this case.

Phone: 4807824000
You can remain anonymous